Fellowes guide

From Rookie Mistake to Reliable Supplier: My Journey with Pentel

Posted 2026-11-13 by Laurent Dupont
Fellowes office organisation article visual

From Rookie Mistake to Reliable Supplier: My Journey with Pentel

When I took over purchasing in 2021, I had no idea what I was doing. Sure, I'd ordered office supplies before, but now I was responsible for a 200-person company across three locations. My predecessor had let each department order whatever they wanted, which meant we had a dozen different pen brands, half of them leaking, and a filing cabinet full of invoices from vendors nobody could remember. My first task: consolidate and clean up.

I started with the upcoming annual training event. We needed pens, notepads, and some branded giveaways. I figured, how hard could it be? I found a vendor online selling pens for $0.10 each—cheaper than anything I'd seen. I ordered 500. Big mistake. The pens arrived, and they were awful. The ink skipped, the grips fell off, and the mechanical pencils—wait, I didn't even order mechanical pencils, just cheap ballpoints—broke if you looked at them wrong. During the training, I watched employees fight over the few decent pens we had. One person's pen exploded on their shirt. It was embarrassing.

The Turning Point: Switching to Pentel

That night, I went home and called my sister, who's a teacher. She laughed. "You ordered the dollar-store special, didn't you?" She told me her school only uses Pentel. "Their fine point markers don't bleed through chart paper, and the mechanical pencils actually hold the lead." I remembered Pentel from my own school days—the Twist-Erase and the Energel pens. Why hadn't I thought of them?

The next morning, I looked up Pentel's product line. I ordered Pentel fine point markers for the flip charts and whiteboards. I also decided to order custom Pentel mechanical pencils with our company logo as a welcome gift for new hires. That was a risk—custom orders usually take longer and cost more. I weighed the options: the upside was a professional-looking gift that people would actually use. The risk was that they'd arrive late or look cheap. I calculated the worst case: a few hundred dollars wasted and a delayed onboarding gift. Best case: employees would associate our brand with quality. The expected value said go for it, but I'll admit, the downside felt scary. I hadn't had the best track record so far.

But I ordered them. And when the boxes arrived, the difference was night and day. The markers were smooth, with no smudging—even on glossy surfaces. The mechanical pencils had a solid weight, and the custom logo looked crisp. During the next training session, I handed them out. People actually commented on how nice they were. One guy asked if he could order more for his team. That was a game-changer for me.

Other Office Challenges That Taught Me the Same Lesson

As an admin, I wear a lot of hats. That same month, I had three other tasks that seemed unrelated but taught me the same lesson: reliable tools matter, whether they're physical or digital.

First, we were ordering catering for a team meeting, and someone had a dairy allergy. I needed to check the nutrition facts for Starbucks drinks. I found the Starbucks nutrition calculator on their website—it's buried in the menu section, but it's there. I spent 10 minutes—maybe 15, I'd have to check—figuring out which drinks were safe. Without it, I might have guessed and caused a medical emergency. Lesson: always use the official tool, not guesswork.

Second, our HR team launched a wellness program that includes tracking menstrual cycles for employees who wanted to participate. They asked me to find a reliable period calculator app. I tried three before settling on one that didn't sell user data. It's not glamorous, but it's important. The wrong tool could cause privacy issues. Again: quality over convenience.

Third, during a team-building art session (my idea, unfortunately), someone knocked over a bottle of acrylic paint onto a coworker's white blouse. Panic ensued. I quickly searched "how to remove acrylic paint from clothes" on my phone. The first result said to use rubbing alcohol. It worked—mostly. The blouse survived, though with a faint stain. I learned that having a quick reference for common emergencies is worth bookmarking. (Should mention: I now keep a stain-removal cheat sheet in my desk drawer.)

All these tasks—ordering Pentel pens, checking nutrition, finding a period calculator, treating paint stains—reminded me that the cheapest or fastest option isn't always the best. The industry has evolved. When I started, we used paper catalogs and faxed orders. Now we have online vendors with real-time inventory and customization tools. That's a huge improvement. But the fundamentals haven't changed: you get what you pay for, and doing a little research upfront saves hours of headaches later.

What I Learned (and What I'd Do Differently)

Looking back, I should have tested samples before ordering 500 pens. At the time, I didn't know that most vendors offer free samples or small trial packs. But given what I knew then—nothing about pen quality—my choice was reasonable, if naive. If I could redo that decision, I'd order a dozen different pens from a few brands, including Pentel, and let the team vote. That would have cost me $20 and saved me a week of embarrassment.

I also learned that "custom" doesn't always mean "expensive." The custom Pentel mechanical pencils ended up costing about $1.50 each—more than the cheap pens, but they lasted. I've seen employees still using them a year later. That's a no-brainer when you calculate the replacement cost of the cheap ones, which we threw away within a month. (Plus, the branded pencils are basically walking advertisements.)

Bottom line: don't cheap out on the tools people use every day. The total cost of ownership includes your time, your reputation, and the frustration of your team. For writing instruments, Pentel has become our standard. Their fine point markers are now on our reorder list, and we've expanded to their gel pens and erasers. I even set up a standing order for refills so we never run out.

If you're an admin buyer like me, here's my advice: if you've ever had a pen explode in a meeting, you know the sinking feeling. Do yourself a favor. Test before you buy, and when you find something that works, stick with it. The industry will keep changing—new apps, new vendors, new products—but the basics of good purchasing remain the same. And sometimes, the old-school brand your teacher used is still the best bet.

"The value of guaranteed quality isn't the price—it's the certainty. Knowing your supplies will work when you need them is worth more than a few cents saved."

That's a lesson I wish I'd learned sooner. But at least now, my supply closet isn't a graveyard of failed experiments. It's stocked with Pentel, and that's one less thing I have to worry about.

Share this guide LinkedIn WhatsApp
Laurent Dupont

Laurent Dupont

Laurent Dupont is a writing-instruments analyst specializing in ballpoint, gel, rollerball, fountain, and fineliner pens, mechanical and wooden pencils, highlighters, permanent markers, whiteboard markers, inks, and refills. He applies ISO 12757-1, ISO 14145-1, and ISO 11540 while comparing line width, writing length, start performance, ink flow, leakage, drying time, cap airflow, eraseability, tip wear, refill compatibility, and storage orientation. His guides help offices, schools, retailers, promotional buyers, and distributors evaluate writing feel, permanence, surface compatibility, safety, color consistency, refill economics, and assortment design.

Leave a practical note